top of page
NEW Newfangled  Logo 2.12.png
menu


meatloaf sandwiches
*gluten free bread available $2, meatloaf is NOT gluten free


the fang
meatloaf, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, american cheese, fang sauce on bun
$11


joe cool
chilled meatloaf, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, ketchup, white bread
$10.50


lucifer's hammer
meatloaf, jalapenos, pepperjack cheese, diablo sauce, lettuce, tomato on bun
$11


southern melt
meatloaf, spicy pimento cheese, tomato, red onion, marbled rye, grilled
$11.50


swiss'shroom melt
meatloaf, portabellos, swiss, fang sauce, marbled rye, grilled
$11.50


meatloaf reuben
meatloaf, cole slaw, swiss cheese, fang sauce grilled on marbled rye
$11.50



hot & grilled sandwiches
*gluten free bread available $2


georgia reuben
turkey, swiss, cole slaw, fang sauce, marbled rye, grilled
$11.25


shipyard tuna melt
tuna salad, mayo, dijon mustard, pickles, white cheddar, marbled rye, grilled
$11


bella donna
portabellas, roasted red pepper, spinach, tomato, mozzarella, fang sauce, whole wheat, grilled
$11.25
Vegetarian


low country grilled cheese
spicy pimento cheese, american cheese, tomato, red onion, on marble rye. add bacon $1.50
$10
Vegetarian


the big deal
grilled bologna, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo on bun
$11


the potsie
grilled bologna, red onion, mustard, mayo, white bread
$10.50


cluck old hen
roasted chicken, lettuce, tomato, fang sauce on bun
$10.25


hunter s chicken
roasted chicken, lettuce, tomato, bbq sauce, bacon, white cheddar on bun
$11.25


NK reuben
corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss & russian dressing grilled on marbled rye
$14.25


devil went down to georgia
turkey, jalapenos, cole slaw, pepperjack cheese & diablo sauce grilled on marbled rye
$11.50



cold sandwiches
*gluten free bread available $2


chatty kathy
chicken salad, white cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato & honey dijon sauce on marbled rye
$11.25


barnyard caviar
egg salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo on marbled rye
$10.75


high five
turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, white cheddar & mayo on toasted white bread
$11.25


Joe Brrr...
turkey, corned beef, cole slaw, swiss & russian dressing on marbled rye
$13.25



classic deli sandwiches
*gluten free bread available $2


corned beef
corned beef, lettuce, tomato on marbled rye
$12.75


turkey
turkey, lettuce, tomato on marbled rye
$10.25


ham
ham, lettuce, tomato on marbled rye
$9.75


chicken salad
chicken salad, lettuce, tomato on marbled rye
$9.75


tuna salad
tuna salad, lettuce, tomato on marbled rye
$9.75


egg salad
egg salad, lettuce, tomato on marbled rye
$9.50



salads
Sm or Lg / add roast chicken, chicken salad, tuna salad, or egg salad for $3.50


pecan dijon
spring mix & kale, bacon, tomato, egg, mozzarella, spiced pecans, honey dijon dressing $10.50/$15.50
Size
300 gr
400 gr
Small$7.75
pecan dijon


tuna nicoise
spring mix & kale, red potatoes, Eric's pickled green beans, tomato, kalamata olives, hard boiled egg, tuna salad, house vinaigrette dressing $10.50/$15.50


garden salad
spring mix & kale, tomato, pickled green beans, roasted red peppers, red cabbage, carrots, ranch dressing $8.25/$13.50
Vegetarian


asian salad
spring mix & kale, red cabbage, edamame, cashews, roasted red peppers, carrots, sesame-ginger dressing $9.00/$14.25
Vegetarian



kids menu
*gluten free bread available $2, meatloaf is NOT gluten free


kid's fang
small meatloaf, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, american cheese and fang sauce on bun
$8.25


kids meatloaf sandwich
$6


kids grilled cheese
$4.50
Vegetarian


kids turkey sandwich
$5.75


kids ham sandwich
$5.50



sides and dessert
sides and dessert



dill pickle potato salad
$3.50


cole slaw
$3.50


soft pretzels & pimento cheese
two soft pretzels with 4 oz. famous homemade pimento cheese
$6.75


carolina kettle potato chips
$3.25


chocolate kettle chip cookie
$3.25

tasting columbus.png
614 magazine.png
youtube-new-logo-1068x297.jpg
navigator.jpg
columbusmonthly_logo.jpg
columbusparent_logo.png
columbus alive logo.png
navigator.jpg
Columbus-Dispatch-Logo.jpg
columbus underground logo.png
columbus navigator logo.jpg
Yelp!

Best Sandwich 
shop in Ohio!

bottom of page